CONSTITUTIONAL COURT RULING: ‘Failure to Give Inmates Newspapers and Magazines Violates Freedom of Expression’

CONSTITUTIONAL COURT RULING: ‘Failure to Give Inmates Newspapers and Magazines Violates Freedom of Expression’

Comments Off on CONSTITUTIONAL COURT RULING: ‘Failure to Give Inmates Newspapers and Magazines Violates Freedom of Expression’

Click to read the article in Turkish

Examining the applications of inmates who were prevented from accessing certain newspapers and magazines in several prisons across Turkey, the Constitutional Court has ruled that their freedom of expression guaranteed by the Article 26 of the Constitution has been violated.

In the verdict of the Constitutional Court, it has been indicated that “rather than the personal conditions of inmates, categorical reasons such as whether they are convicted of a terror crime and whether they are incarcerated in a high-security prison are effective in preventing them from accessing newspapers and magazines.”

The Court has also ruled that there is “an extreme arbitrariness” among different penal institutions when it comes to evaluating whether the same publication is given to inmates and convicts with the same status.

‘No mechanisms in place to prevent arbitrariness’

In its verdict no. 2016/12936 entitled “Recep Bekik and Others”, the Constitutional Court has also expressed the opinion that “there is not a system in place to prevent arbitrariness” in that regard.

Moreover, the court has concluded that in evaluating to decide whether they will accept the newspapers and magazines or not, the prisons do not follow “consistent criteria as put forward by the Constitutional Court.”

‘A structural problem in the system’

In its ruling, the Constitutional Court has underlined that several verdicts of violation given by the Court are not taken into account in practice:

“Though the Constitutional Court has given several verdicts of violation on the same issue until today, the interventions of this nature and individual applications against them are continuing.”

In its ruling, the court has also referred to “a structural problem” in the current system when it comes to accepting publications to penal institutions.

Accordingly, referring to the Article 26 of the Constitution in the light of these justifications, the Constitutional Court has ruled that the freedom of expression of the applicants has been violated.

What happened?

Certain issues of newspapers and magazines bought by the inmates in several high-security prisons were not given to them in accordance with the decisions of penal institutions’ educational institutions though there was not a verdict of confiscation given for these publications.

In the related decisions of the educational institutions, it was stated that the publications in question were not allowed to enter the prisons on the ground that “there were content praising the terrorist organization and its leader and constituting terror propaganda in them.”

The judgeships of execution objected to the complaints that were filed by the inmates against these decisions and the heavy penal courts did not accept their objections against these rejections, either. In response, several inmates appealed to the Constitutional Court. Making a joint evaluation on these applications, the court has given a single ruling. (AS/SD)

admin

Related Posts

Die Welt Journalist Deniz Yücel Arrested

Comments Off on Die Welt Journalist Deniz Yücel Arrested

Trial of Gülmen, Özakça on Hunger For 189 Days Begins Tomorrow

Comments Off on Trial of Gülmen, Özakça on Hunger For 189 Days Begins Tomorrow

The Netherlands Withdraws Ambassador to Turkey

Comments Off on The Netherlands Withdraws Ambassador to Turkey

Diyarbakır Bar: Shooting of Kurkut is a Violation of Right to Live

Comments Off on Diyarbakır Bar: Shooting of Kurkut is a Violation of Right to Live

3 Suspects Detained in Relation With Poisoning of Dogs in Ankara Released

Comments Off on 3 Suspects Detained in Relation With Poisoning of Dogs in Ankara Released

3rd Hearing of Büyükada Trial Begins

Comments Off on 3rd Hearing of Büyükada Trial Begins

Parliamentary Inquiry into Hrant Dink Murder Rejected

Comments Off on Parliamentary Inquiry into Hrant Dink Murder Rejected

TRIAL OF ACADEMICS: Deferred Prison Sentence of 1 Year, 3 Months for One Academic

Comments Off on TRIAL OF ACADEMICS: Deferred Prison Sentence of 1 Year, 3 Months for One Academic

Iranian President Rouhani’s brother detained

Comments Off on Iranian President Rouhani’s brother detained

The decision about the new Life newspaper

Comments Off on The decision about the new Life newspaper

Reactions Against Discharges of Academics: ‘Boss Has Gone Crazy’

Comments Off on Reactions Against Discharges of Academics: ‘Boss Has Gone Crazy’

Verdicts of Acquittal Upheld in Ceylanpınar Case

Comments Off on Verdicts of Acquittal Upheld in Ceylanpınar Case

Create Account



Log In Your Account